How I Secured the Best PM Salary Increase

As a junior employee, I used to believe that salary was something the organization gave you – a fixed reward that only changed when you switched jobs. The only way to get a significant pay raise, I thought, was to find another employer offering more.

But as I climbed the corporate ladder and learned the dynamics of the workplace, I discovered that salary wasn’t just handed out – it was negotiated. I also became part of the group that decides salaries, which gave me invaluable insights into how these discussions play out behind closed doors. That experience allowed me to develop a playbook that PMs can use to get closer to their desired salary hike.

If you’re a Product Manager trying to land the best possible raise, here's my step-by-step guide to navigating the process strategically.

1. Time It Well – Stay Visible Throughout the Year

The biggest mistake you can make is waiting until appraisal time to advocate for a raise. Salary decisions aren’t just made during performance reviews – they are shaped by how visible you are to decision-makers throughout the year. If your achievements aren’t top of mind for your manager when it matters, you’ll struggle to secure the hike you want.

Proactive Visibility Tactics for PMs:

- Regular check-ins: Schedule a meeting with your manager every 8-10 weeks. Use this time to:

- Highlight your accomplishments: What goals have you hit?

- Share lessons learned: What did you learn from a failed or successful product iteration?

- Show added value: How did your work contribute to product growth or customer satisfaction?

- Present future plans: What are your next steps to create value?

Script for a Check-in Meeting:

 "Hi [Manager], I wanted to walk you through some progress I've made over the last few weeks. We shipped [feature] that impacted [metric], and I also received feedback from [stakeholders] that it’s improving [customer metric]. I’ve learned [key lesson], and I’d love your feedback on how I can make an even bigger impact moving forward."

2. Structure the Conversation – Avoid Directly Asking for a Hike Too Soon 

Managers dislike conversations that begin with "I need a hike." Salary increases are complicated decisions, and your manager might feel frustrated because they don’t have sole control over the outcome. Often, raises involve input from multiple decision-makers – HR, Finance, and leadership teams – leaving managers feeling restricted.

Instead, focus the discussion on your performance and development. Keep conversations about hikes indirect initially. This primes your manager over time and makes the final conversation during appraisal easier.

Key Discussion Strategy: 

- Ask for feedback regularly: During your check-ins, request feedback on your work and specific areas for improvement.

- Demonstrate action: In follow-up meetings, show how you acted on the feedback you received.

Script for Asking for Feedback:

 "I’d love to hear your thoughts on how I performed on [specific project]. Was there anything I could have done differently to increase its impact? I want to make sure I’m improving with every project."

When you act on feedback, it makes your progress visible and signals that you are consistently developing – a key point for salary discussions.

3. Collect Data – Build Your Case with Metrics 

As a PM, numbers are your best friend. If you want a solid raise, you need to back up your performance with hard data. Create a personal progress report that tracks all the KPIs you’ve influenced over the past 9-12 months. This report should be dynamic – updating it continuously makes it easy to show both short-term wins and long-term growth whenever the opportunity arises.

Here’s what your report should cover:

- Customer metrics: NPS, retention rates, or customer satisfaction improvement.

- Business metrics: Revenue contribution, cost savings, or churn reduction.

- Product metrics: Feature adoption, bug fixes, or roadmap delivery percentage.

When metrics move in the right direction, it’s hard for anyone to argue against your value.

Script for Sharing Your Personal Progress Report:

 "Over the past few months, I’ve been tracking the KPIs we discussed. Here’s a snapshot of the progress so far: [highlight key KPIs]. I believe these numbers show the impact I’ve had. I'd like to understand what further impact you’d like to see so I can align my efforts toward even bigger results."

4. Counter Objections – Prepare for Pushbacks 

Managers sometimes deflect the conversation despite stellar metrics by attributing success to other teams or external factors. They may also downplay the project’s impact to limit the scope for a raise. If this happens, you need to control the narrative by clearly justifying your role and the importance of your contributions.

Here’s how to prepare:

- Know the full context: Be aware of cross-functional dependencies and clearly show how your work contributed to the success of the product.

- Reframe deflection: If the success is attributed to other teams, highlight your collaboration and leadership in driving the initiative.

- Ask for new opportunities: If a project’s impact is dismissed, request ownership of higher-impact work and set expectations for what success looks like.

Script for Handling Pushback:

 "I understand this project was a team effort, and I’m grateful to have collaborated with [other teams]. However, I believe my role in driving [specific aspect] was crucial to [the result]. If this isn’t aligned with the kind of impact you expect, I’d love to discuss opportunities to take on more challenging projects."

5. Set the Stage for the Final Conversation – Frame Your Ask Thoughtfully

By the time appraisal season rolls around, your manager should already have a positive impression of your performance and contribution. Your earlier efforts – regular visibility, structured discussions, data tracking, and handling objections – will prime them to view your request for a raise favorably. Now it’s time to make your ask, but frame it thoughtfully.

Script for the Final Conversation:

 "Over the past year, I’ve focused on driving measurable impact with my work. As we discussed earlier, I’ve tracked metrics like [key metric], which show [specific result]. Given the outcomes and feedback we’ve discussed over the year, I believe my contributions align with a higher level of compensation. What steps can we take to ensure my role is recognized appropriately?"

This framing ensures that:

- Your manager sees your ask as logical and data-backed.

- You invite them into a collaborative discussion rather than issuing a demand.

- It keeps the focus on your value and future contributions, setting the tone for an ongoing conversation about growth.

The Bottom Line – Salary Increases Are Earned, Not Given 

The biggest lesson I learned from being on both sides of the salary conversation is that raises are not something that just happens. They are the result of consistent, intentional efforts to show your value and align your work with the company’s goals. For Product Managers, it’s all about visibility, metrics, and strategic conversations.

If you stay proactive and play it right, you’ll not only increase your chances of getting the raise you want, but you’ll also strengthen your reputation as a high-impact, growth-oriented Product Manager.

Good luck with your next salary negotiation – you've got this!

Ready to Take the Next Step?

If you found these insights helpful, let’s take it further,

• Land your dream job with personalized career coaching.

  Book 1:1 call

• Thrive in your current role by mastering career strategies and navigating challenges effectively.

• I have created a job portal that will give you access to High paying Best PM Jobs in the US - before they get flooded with applications - Visit BestPMJobs.com 

Let’s work together to unlock the career and salary growth you deserve!

If you have any questions, reply to this email and I will be happy to help.

Wishing you a week filled with positive updates for your job.

I will see you next week.

All the Best

Aditi